For several years during that era, it was noticeable that when people switched doors, they got the answer 2/3 of the time while those who didn't got the award 1/3 of the time. Why?
There is actually a bit of math involved. Let's start simple. Picking one door door would give you 1/3 of a chance of getting a prize. Thus you would have 2/3 of a chance picking the wrong door. 1/3+2/3=1. From this you would know that two doors together would have a probability of 2/3 getting the prize. Here's where it gets interesting when he reveals one of the wrong doors. Remember that we already established that the probability of two doors together is 2/3. Staying with your initial choice. Additionally, your initial choice will always be 1/3 of success. If montee hall didn't remove a door, and you changed your mind there are 2 doors to choose from and there is a 2/3 success rate of two doors. Thus, (1/2)(2/3)=2/6=1/3 just like your initial choice. Since he did remove one, you only have one other choice to choose from and remember that two doors has a success rate of 2/3. Therefore 1(2/3)=2/3 probability of success if you switch. Same concept works for four doors. If he didn't remove a door, you have 3 other doors to choose from and a 3/4 success rate of three doors. Thus (1/3)(3/4)=3/12 probability which is just like an initial choice of 1/4 success rate. If he does remove a door there are only two doors to choose from. Thus (1/2)(3/4)=3/8 which is greater than 1/4. Therefore you should always switch doors.
http://montyhallproblem.com
Wow so such complicated. I guess it is always better to change your choice since there is a high possibility to win.
ReplyDelete